Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Peter Shepherd's avatar

Nicely said

Expand full comment
Toma's avatar

The second amendment in no way, shape or form applies to the Zimmermann case. It should have never even been considered let alone applied. It was murder, premeditated and should have ended there with Zimmerman being found guilty. The same twisted logic is being applied to suppress protests on college campuses by one person feeling "unsafe" to suppress a majority.

The second amendment only applies to foreign invaders or the government at the federal or state level becoming tyrannical. It does not even allude to individual rights to commit murder or self defense. The "justice system" is not a "justice system" any longer. It is a system being used to justify criminal activity for the political economic and corporate system.

The first amendment gives the people the right to protest for a redress of grievances which has been taken away as can clearly be seen by the current actions of the government at the state and federal level. The people's "grievances" are being completely ignored by our elected officials. Our rights to protest and freedom of speech have been taken away. The right to declare bankruptcy has been taken away. The right to an attorney has been taken away. If declared a terrorist which has no clear definition ALL rights are taken away. Murder of an unarmed teenager however is considered self defense.

A true militia does not currently exist in the US. A militia is comprised of non military citizens in an individual state. The national guard is a part of the federal armed forces and not a true militia. This was something that was impossible to foreee when the constitution was written 250 years ago as are many other things in todays society.

If one reads the declaration of independence the majority of reasons for separation from England are present today and many are far worse. The problem is not in the constitution, it's in the failure of the government to update the constitution as well as the bogus reinterpretation of the constitution with the Zimmermann case being a prime example. Nowhere does it say in the constitution that a permit is needed to protest. It is a gauranteed right under the Bill of Rights. Yet universities are suppressing that constitutional right by saying that protestors must abide by university rules to protest. If the university puts a sign up "Keep off the grass" one can be arrested for criminal trespassing. Our "rights" have been taken away by reinterpretation of the constitution.

When the constitution was written it was never envisioned that a federal id would be instituted and yet even in that era one could have been issued. Yet today we have one called The RealID and it is required to obtain a job, vote, drivers license etc.

If we were to say "It's a sad day for democracy in America." what day would that be? Today? Yesterday? A century ago? It has been slowly eroded by the passage of time. My opinion is that the death blow came with the implementation of the Patriot Act. Something that Obama, a constitutional scholar failed to repeal and in fact supported and used against Edward Snowden. Now, today is a sad day for the world at large because of America. Either Americans are going to have to implement the changes internally or the changes will come externally from other countries. It would be far better from within for all.

Expand full comment
3 more comments...

No posts