Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Palestine Will Be Free's avatar

Much needed piece, Aya. Thank you for writing it. I have some very minor quibbles about this but let's keep them aside for the time being.

Also, while we are acknowledging the tyranny of the Assads and the fact that an extremely tiny minority trampled over the hopes and aspirations of the vast majority of Syrians, I don't like the fact that a lot of Sunni commentators are completely ignoring the Israeli and American hand behind al-Julani and his men. As you write, it's not that hard to acknowledge the fall of Assad as a good thing for the oppressed Syrians and that their liberators have an extremely shady background.

Expand full comment
Punditman's avatar

Are any of the four mentioned actual experts? Or simply commentators, or polemicists? Murray is a former diplomat with obvious blind spots.Johnstone is an engaging writer but her world view is pretty narrow and she gets obnoxious when challenged. Petty and nasty. I gave up on her when I got into it with one of her readers to whom facts meant nothing. To some extent, you are the company you keep and a portion of the "anti-imperialist" left is very cult-like. It's full of tankies too. I don't know about the track record or background of Medhurst or Miller. But for me, a true expert is capable of holding varying ideas and nuance in their head at the same time without suffering cognitive dissonance and doubling down on deflective b.s. when their "ideas" fall flat.

Expand full comment
33 more comments...

No posts